In preparation for our upcoming birth, I have (finally) started to do some reading. Just before getting pregnant the first time, I started the
DONA (Doulas of North America) certification program which involved a few seminars, and a
heavy reading list. It was something I had always wanted to do, but a good friends imminent birth had jump started me into. The timing was extremely beneficial, since I ended up getting pregnant 3 months after starting. By the time my friends birth came along, I had to be the most well read and
least experienced doula in the world. I often reflect on her birth and think how lucky I was to be there... not for her sake, but for my own- I learned
so much. It often feels very selfish of me to have attended! In addition to all the books I read, we took at 12 week
Bradley Childbirth Education course (more on that to come).
This time around... not so much. Here I am, 30 weeks pregnant today; and I just cracked open a birth book for the first time
last night. And, if you can believe it, I am reading
Ina May's Guide to Childbirth
for
the first time. I am a little ashamed to admit it, but until now I hadn't read
any Ina May. But, I read the first half of the book last night, so I'm fixing that promptly.
The first half of the book is a compilation of positive birth stories. In America, the idea of childbirth has been portrayed as a big, painful, medical event. And it's not just in the media... it's the way everyone from obstetricians to your great aunt talk about it... it's part of our collective consciousness. Ina May tries to undo that by sharing more than 40 unmedicated birth stories with strong, positive outcomes. They are not without complications, but all are beautiful examples of how strong the female body is. They are meant to empower women into believing in their bodies, and help start to change our idea of what "giving birth" entails. It has motivated me to reflect on my first birth and "rewrite" Tank's birth story. (The first time around, it was all details, facts, and times. I never really reflected on what was happening internally. Look for a post soon. ;)
I have just started the second half of the book, which she titles "the essentials of birth" and it is more a collection of birthing wisdom than a how-to directive. She discusses the powers of: mind over body, movement, and utilizing gravity, along with giving an overall description of what normal, natural birth looks like. This last topic I find to be frightening... not that natural birth is frighting, but that most people have no idea what natural birth looks like. There are several named examples (and I am sure there are many more unnamed) in the book of obstetricians visiting
The Farm to witness it for *the first time*... in all of their internships and training, they had never seen a normal, natural birth. Oi! (And we are expected to follow their "advice" while giving birth?!) My guess is that since there really isn't a "normal" progression for a normal, natural childbirth, it is too difficult to teach ;)
Anyway, all of this to say... I just read something that gave me the weirdest idea. And I had to share.
"The problem is that doctors today often assume that something mysterious and unidentified has gone wrong with labor or that the woman's body is somehow "inadequate" -- what I call the "woman's body as a lemon" assumption. For a variety of reasons, a lot of women have also come to believe that nature made a serious mistake with their bodies. This belief has become so strong in many that they give in to pharmaceutical or surgical treatments when patience and recognition of the normality and harmlessness of the situation would make for better health for them and their babies... Remember this, for this is as true as it gets: Your body is not a lemon. You are not a machine. The creator is not a careless mechanic. Human female bodies have the same potential to give birth well as aardvarks, lions, rhinoceri, elephants, moose, and water buffalo." (Gaskin, 2003)
So... having the background in science that I do... I started to wonder: What would happen if we "gifted" these animals- these aardvarks, lions, rhinoceri, elphants, moose, and water buffalo- with the same "gifts" we give laboring women: epidurals? Have any other mammals been given epidrurals in labor? It is cruel and unusual to "relieve" other animals of the pain of birth? What would the animal ethics board
even do with this suggestion? If we see epidurals as a welcome relief for our own species, wouldn't your average horse also appreciate one?
Now, I am guessing that the breakdown of this would be in ability to communicate intelligently. You can't explain to an aardvark that it's OK that they have no control over the lower half of their bodies, it's an intentional effect that will wear off soon. You also can't really check the cervix of an aardvark to tell her when it's OK to push, and you certainly can't direct her pushing. Even just thinking these things sound totally cruel and ridiculous- but is it really? If it is what we do to help laboring human women, why does it seem just plain mean to do it to other mammals?
Anyway, that's just todays installment of "weird thoughts with Paige". If you have any insight to this, I would really love to hear it!
*************************
Gaskin, I. M. (2003). Ina May's Guide to Childbirth. (pp. 141-142). New York, NY: Bantam Dell.